I’m not a fan of these shows where they do a reboot and change the gender of the character (usually a woman). Like the suggestion here to do James Bond as a woman.
But first things first: I’m all for having great roles for women characters in films, TV, and books–and a range of ages. The Wonder Woman movie was huge because it was an iconic character and they did it right. Some TV shows on now that work:
- The Orville. Huge cast with a lot of women. They’ve dressed all the women in the same uniform as the men (Star Trek: The Next Generation, I’m looking at you!). And the roles are good for all the actors.
- The Good Place. I don’t want to say too much about this one because if you haven’t seen it, it’s way too easy to give the story away. Again, the whole cast–men and women–have good roles.
Onto my issues with the gender-swapping…
Characters are not interchangeable.
If a reboot switches out a character with another type of character, it’s going to change the story in fundamental ways and, likely break something that people liked about the original.
Some roles don’t fit the opposite gender
And I know there’s a group of writers out there who think the genders are interchangeable. But there are some roles where if they were flipped, it would not look good on that gender. I’d like to do a story about a woman lone gun like Jack Reacher, and I’m having to really think about how to do it properly so people enjoy the story, not hate the character.
It disrespects the old show or movie.
It’s like saying, “It wasn’t good enough because it didn’t have this type of character.” There’s been a lot of that conceit from all these reboots, where it’s obvious the studios only saw the title as a moneymaker and made no effort to understand why audiences liked the original. I still remember discussion about the Fantasy Island reboot where the studios said they wanted to “improve” it by making it darker. They entirely missed the point of the original show, and it got cancelled pretty fast.
Why can’t they create new original works?!!
Seriously. We don’t need gender swapping in reboots or ongoing franchises. Create new stories with the characters they want and make new films and shows that might be one day be loved the same way.